Liam Williams

link for anyone who's not read the comments.  Reading between the lines he was in talks with Cardiff and Dai Young for a long time and you have to question how he could play well for wales whilst often being anonymous for us, on those occasions he did play.  Someone who's not worried about defamation could infer he did his best to force the move...but I categorically wouldn't say that. 

Thanks for your service Sanj, the first stint will always be remembered fondly.

It really seemed as if he didn't want to be here. Best for everyone, especially the Scarlets,  that he left.

He was a fantastic asset to us in his first spell, and I am grateful to him for all the entertainment.

In his 2nd stint he was at times, an idiot. Let's be honest. I think his first game back after a lengthy spell ended in a red card for a ridiculous tackle. And it didn't really get much better until his final few weeks.

These days it seems clear to me that we are trying to build a team around fewer players who are team Wales first choice, for lots of reasons including consistency of selection. I am personally wholeheartedly behind that strategy. 

That cheap shot streak seemed to have have been knocked out of him at Saracens, but it returned again last year. 

He has a ton of talent and is very courageous, but once in a while the red mist he gets lets him down.  Other than the above incident, he has been a great asset to Wales, and the Lions, and good luck to him in his new life.

Agree, I don't think it's an over-reaction. 

As it's already been stated, he was great in his first stint with us.

Wayne Pivac told me, that part of the reason he moved to Sarries , was his on -going relationship, & also obviously joining a top team capable of winning things, was an attraction.

I wished him well with that, and he did fine up there !.

Was pleased when he returned only to be so disappointed by reckless play (costing us points & games), ineffective displays, and a lack of commitment to playing at all.

We are better off without him.

Maybe a comparison in cricket is "Welsh Fire", a bunch of mercenaries, with NO FIRE in their bellies

Maybe sums up some aspects of modern sport

Bring back the old tribal and ultra-parochial...LOL !

Sad.  Him I mean.

As is our reaction to his petulant and silly comments.

We know that he is being influenced.

We also know that a rugby players career is short, so he is chasing the money.

I do not regret his departure.

The Scarlets are strong enough to survive without a 'celebrity' player.