| Author |
Topic Search Topic Options
|
Alun
Veteran
Joined: 20 March 2005
Location: Ar lan y mor
Status: Offline
Points: 8268
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Topic: Law test Posted: 16 May 2011 at 2:14am |
This is taken off another forum (Protected area within the forum), posted by Donal1988, sure he won't mind me re-posting. Give it a shot, without looking at the Law book then!!!
1 - Blue winger in possession deliberately knees the ball over the heads of the advancing White defenders, regains the ball and dives over in the corner. Decision?
2 - Red have a scrum on the Blue 5 metre line, Reds No 8 picks the ball up and bumps into the referee, the opposition players are 2 metres away and are affected by the collision. The No 8 passes the ball to the No 14 who scores in the corner. Decision?
3 - Can you make a tackle if you are on the deck?
4 - At a restart from the halfway line Blue 10 drop kicks the ball and it travels over the 10 metre line but the wind catches it midair and blows it back to before the 10 metre line where blue 7 catches it. Decision?
5 -Red 15 is in his 22 and runs forward to kick left footed for touch. As he does so, his right foot is on his 22 metre line. He kicks directly into the arms of an opposition player who is standing with one foot on the touch line. The ball has not crossed the plane of touch. Who gets the put-in and where?
6 - The ball is passed to blue No 10 who is standing in in-goal, he clears the ball which crosses the goal line but is charged down by red No 7 and goes dead. As he charges the ball down and it goes dead, he follows through with an elbow and catches blue No 10 in the chin. Decision?
7 -Blue No 10 kicks for the corner. The ball bounces inches from the corner and hits the corner flag. As the ball bounces, but before it hits the corner flag Red No 6 late tackles Blue No 10. Decision?
8 - The ball is kicked down the pitch and comes to rest just in front of the 22 metre line. Blue No 15 reaches forward and plucks the ball back into the 22 and kicks the ball to an opponent who has one foot in touch and catches it on the full. Whose put in and where?
9 - When can the defensive back line encroach the 10 metre law at the line-out before the lineout is over?
10 - At what point does the scrum begin?
11 - A free kick is awarded 8 metres into in-goal (its a big ingoal). Where must the opposition stand?
12 - Blue 10 kicks off and the ball bobbles in front of the goal line, Red No15 reaches out and grabs the ball and grounds it over the goal line. Decision?
13 - Blue team throw in at the line-out 5m from their goal-line. They put four players into the lineout, three at the front and one on the 15m line. They throw in. Blue No 6 who is standing on the 15m line catches the ball. His props bind onto him along with the Red forwards, thus forming a Maul. Immediately four of the Blue forwards cross the goal line and start to drive the group of players ahead. Decision?
14 - Blue out-half kicks a kick at goal. Red No 4 reaches up and palms the ball down before it can rise and go over the bar. Decision?
15 - Can you charge down a freekick. If so, at what point?
16 - Blue No 6 passes the ball to Blue No 13 who is 10 metres from the opposition line. As he passes to Blue No 14 who has a free run to the line Red No 12 deliberately knocks on the ball before No 14 can catch it. Decision?
17 -At an under 17 match blue team are awarded a scrum, the hooker successfully heels the ball to the back of the scrum and the number 8 controls the ball at the base and the blue team push 1m with the no. 8 controlling the ball at the base. Is this legal.
18 - Blue No 6 has a blood injury and is replaced by No 19, who is sent off for Foul play after 10 minutes. NO 6 is ready to go back on after 14 minutes and Blue want to take off No 8. Can they do this?
19 - The throwing in team at a lineout put 7 in the lineout. The defence say them only want to put in 5. Is this legal?
20 - Blue No 15 is tactically substituted by No 22 after 50 minutes. This is the only substitution that has been made when after 60 minutes No 22 gets a blood injury and Blue want to put No 15 back on. Can they do this?
|
|
Cartref newydd, Stadiwm newydd, Penod newydd, Yr un freuddwyd.
ARE WE HUMAN, OR ARE WE SCARLET?
All statements are my own personal opinions.
|
 |
|
Sponsored Links
|
|
 |
haydn_davies
Veteran
Joined: 10 April 2009
Location: Llanelli
Status: Online
Points: 5763
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 16 May 2011 at 7:30am |
|
1. Try 2. Scrum 5 Red where he bumped ref 3. No 4. Retake kick or scrum on halfway for red 5. Blue lineout where he catches the ball 6. Penalty to Blue where he was taken out; yellow card to Red 7. 7. Penalty Blue where ball landed; YC Red 6 if serious 8. Red throw on Blue 22m line as he took ball back in to 22 9. If lineout is within 10m of own tryline 10. When the two sides are engaged 11. 10m away 12. Scrum 5m out Blue ball 13. Play on - Maul formed and lineout over 14. As long as Red 4 is 10m away play on; penalty Red if not 15. As long as you are 10m away 16. Penalty to Blue where Red knocked on; possibly YC to Red 12; possibly Pen Try to Blue if try would have been scored 17. Yes 18. Yes (??) 19. No 20. No.
|
|
Think, think, think - it's a thinking man's game!! - The Great Carwyn James.
|
 |
scarletman
Veteran
Married with Kids - Close to Bankruptcy
Joined: 18 August 2004
Location: Wales
Status: Offline
Points: 7268
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 16 May 2011 at 9:31am |
|
Question 17 depends on which Union the Match is taking place under !
|
|
Member of the Official Scarlets Cyclops Choir (Cardiff 2012)
|
 |
scarletman
Veteran
Married with Kids - Close to Bankruptcy
Joined: 18 August 2004
Location: Wales
Status: Offline
Points: 7268
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 16 May 2011 at 9:34am |
|
Q14 doesn't state whether it is a Penalty / Conversion or a Drop Goal !
|
|
Member of the Official Scarlets Cyclops Choir (Cardiff 2012)
|
 |
scarletman
Veteran
Married with Kids - Close to Bankruptcy
Joined: 18 August 2004
Location: Wales
Status: Offline
Points: 7268
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 16 May 2011 at 10:00am |
|
Q11 - You can't award a free kick "in Goal" !
If a FK offence occurs in goal, the FK is on the 5m line in line with the offence !
|
|
Member of the Official Scarlets Cyclops Choir (Cardiff 2012)
|
 |
scarletman
Veteran
Married with Kids - Close to Bankruptcy
Joined: 18 August 2004
Location: Wales
Status: Offline
Points: 7268
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 16 May 2011 at 10:01am |
|
Al ? Where did you get these Questions Mate ? Changleng Refs Academy ?
|
|
Member of the Official Scarlets Cyclops Choir (Cardiff 2012)
|
 |
Alun
Veteran
Joined: 20 March 2005
Location: Ar lan y mor
Status: Offline
Points: 8268
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 16 May 2011 at 11:32am |
scarletman wrote:
Question 17 depends on which Union the Match is taking place under !
|
IRB Under 19 Variations
|
|
Cartref newydd, Stadiwm newydd, Penod newydd, Yr un freuddwyd.
ARE WE HUMAN, OR ARE WE SCARLET?
All statements are my own personal opinions.
|
 |
Alun
Veteran
Joined: 20 March 2005
Location: Ar lan y mor
Status: Offline
Points: 8268
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 16 May 2011 at 11:32am |
scarletman wrote:
Q14 doesn't state whether it is a Penalty / Conversion or a Drop Goal !
|
Penalty kick at goal.
|
|
Cartref newydd, Stadiwm newydd, Penod newydd, Yr un freuddwyd.
ARE WE HUMAN, OR ARE WE SCARLET?
All statements are my own personal opinions.
|
 |
Alun
Veteran
Joined: 20 March 2005
Location: Ar lan y mor
Status: Offline
Points: 8268
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 16 May 2011 at 11:34am |
scarletman wrote:
Q11 - You can't award a free kick "in Goal" !
If a FK offence occurs in goal, the FK is on the 5m line in line with the offence !
|
Just answered the question!
|
|
Cartref newydd, Stadiwm newydd, Penod newydd, Yr un freuddwyd.
ARE WE HUMAN, OR ARE WE SCARLET?
All statements are my own personal opinions.
|
 |
KID A
Moderator Group
Joined: 16 August 2004
Location: Cardiff
Status: Online
Points: 14124
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 16 May 2011 at 2:21pm |
|
I need to see the answers to these!!
|
|
.
.
|
 |
scarletman
Veteran
Married with Kids - Close to Bankruptcy
Joined: 18 August 2004
Location: Wales
Status: Offline
Points: 7268
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 16 May 2011 at 3:59pm |
My take on this !1 - Blue winger in possession deliberately knees the ball over the heads
of the advancing White defenders, regains the ball and dives over in the
corner. Decision?
Scrum Red ... Knock on as the knee is NOT the foot, so
can't be given as a kick.
2 - Red have a scrum on the Blue 5 metre line, Reds No 8 picks the ball up and
bumps into the referee, the opposition players are 2 metres away and are
affected by the collision. The No 8 passes the ball to the No 14 who
scores in the corner. Decision?
Scrum Red 5 Metres !
3 - Can you make a tackle if you are on the deck?
No !
4 - At a restart from the halfway line Blue 10 drop kicks the ball and it
travels over the 10 metre line but the wind catches it midair and blows it back
to before the 10 metre line where blue 7 catches it. Decision?
Play on ! The only law is that the ball has to travel
10 metres, not land 10 metres !
5 -Red 15 is in his 22 and runs forward to kick left footed for touch. As he
does so, his right foot is on his 22 metre line. He kicks directly into the
arms of an opposition player who is standing with one foot on the touch line.
The ball has not crossed the plane of touch. Who gets the put-in and where?
Lineout where the ball was caught by Blue .. Blue Throw
in ! The 22 line is inside the 22, just as the Touch Line is in touch !
6 - The ball is passed to blue No 10 who is standing in in-goal, he clears the
ball which crosses the goal line but is charged down by red No 7 and goes dead.
As he charges the ball down and it goes dead, he follows through with an elbow
and catches blue No 10 in the chin. Decision?
If the Elbow is deemed foul play, Penalty Blue 5m line (Yellow to Red 7)
If not, drop out 22!
7 -Blue No 10 kicks for the corner. The ball bounces inches from the corner and
hits the corner flag. As the ball bounces, but before it hits the corner flag
Red No 6 late tackles Blue No 10. Decision?
Penalty to Blue, 5 & 15 !
8 - The ball is kicked down the pitch and comes to rest just in front of the 22
metre line. Blue No 15 reaches forward and plucks the ball back into the 22 and
kicks the ball to an opponent who has one foot in touch and catches it on the
full. Whose put in and where?
Lineout to Red, from just inside Blue 22
9 - When can the defensive back line encroach the 10 metre law at the line-out
before the lineout is over?
When the Lineout is on the 5 metre line !
10 - At what point does the scrum begin?
When the ball leaves the Scrum Halfs' hand
11 - A free kick is awarded 8 metres into in-goal (its a big ingoal). Where
must the opposition stand?
Can’t award a Free Kick in goal .. Free kick would be
awarded 5m line in line with the offence, oppostiton to be 15m from goal line.
12 - Blue 10 kicks off and the ball bobbles in front of the goal line, Red No15
reaches out and grabs the ball and grounds it over the goal line. Decision?
22 Dropout as the ball was still moving when he picked it up !
13 - Blue team throw in at the line-out 5m from their goal-line. They put four
players into the lineout, three at the front and one on the 15m line.
They throw in. Blue No 6 who is standing on the 15m line catches the ball. His
props bind onto him along with the Red forwards, thus
forming a Maul. Immediately four of the Blue forwards cross the goal line and
start to drive the group of players ahead. Decision?
Penalty to Red, offside, as the lineout is not over !
14 - Blue out-half kicks a kick at goal. Red No 4 reaches up and palms the ball
down before it can rise and go over the bar. Decision?
Presuming it was a penalty, award a new penalty 10m from the original kick.
You can’t charge a penalty. Warn player!
15 - Can you charge down a freekick. If so, at what point?
Yes, immediately once the defender has retired 10 metres.
16 - Blue No 6 passes the ball to Blue No 13 who is 10 metres from the
opposition line. As he passes to Blue No 14 who has a free run to the
line Red No 12 deliberately knocks on the ball before No 14 can catch it.
Decision?
If the actions of Red 12 prevents a probable score (in the mind of the official)
award a Penalty Try, & Yellow to Red 12.
17 -At an under 17 match blue team are awarded a scrum, the hooker successfully
heels the ball to the back of the scrum and the number 8
controls the ball at the base and the blue team push 1m with the no. 8
controlling the ball at the base. Is this legal.
The ball must be released from the scrum immediately it reaches the No.8’s
feet. Free Kick to Red.
18 - Blue No 6 has a blood injury and is replaced by No 19, who is sent off for
Foul play after 10 minutes. NO 6 is ready to go back on after 14 minutes and
Blue want to take off No 8. Can they do this?
No, (The Blue 19 is deemed to
have been sent off in lieu of Blue 6 !)
19 - The throwing in team at a lineout put 7 in the lineout. The defence say
them only want to put in 5. Is this legal?
Yes ! The Throwing side determines the Maximum Numbers not Minimum.
20 - Blue No 15 is tactically substituted by No 22 after 50 minutes. This is
the only substitution that has been made when after 60 minutes No 22 gets a
blood injury and Blue want to put No 15 back on. Can they do this? Yes a Substituted player can replace a player with a blood injury.
Edited by scarletman - 16 May 2011 at 4:03pm
|
|
Member of the Official Scarlets Cyclops Choir (Cardiff 2012)
|
 |
geej123
Newbie
Joined: 01 January 2011
Location: Newport
Status: Offline
Points: 36
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 17 May 2011 at 1:22pm |
scarletman wrote:
My take on this !
1 - Blue winger in possession deliberately knees the ball over the heads of the advancing White defenders, regains the ball and dives over in the corner. Decision? Scrum Red ... Knock on as the knee is NOT the foot, so can't be given as a kick.
Would this be a knock on as it does touch another player or the ground?
2 - Red have a scrum on the Blue 5 metre line, Reds No 8 picks the ball up and bumps into the referee, the opposition players are 2 metres away and are affected by the collision. The No 8 passes the ball to the No 14 who scores in the corner. Decision? Scrum Red 5 Metres !
3 - Can you make a tackle if you are on the deck? No !
4 - At a restart from the halfway line Blue 10 drop kicks the ball and it travels over the 10 metre line but the wind catches it midair and blows it back to before the 10 metre line where blue 7 catches it. Decision? Play on ! The only law is that the ball has to travel 10 metres, not land 10 metres !
5 -Red 15 is in his 22 and runs forward to kick left footed for touch. As he does so, his right foot is on his 22 metre line. He kicks directly into the arms of an opposition player who is standing with one foot on the touch line. The ball has not crossed the plane of touch. Who gets the put-in and where? Lineout where the ball was caught by Blue .. Blue Throw in ! The 22 line is inside the 22, just as the Touch Line is in touch !
6 - The ball is passed to blue No 10 who is standing in in-goal, he clears the ball which crosses the goal line but is charged down by red No 7 and goes dead. As he charges the ball down and it goes dead, he follows through with an elbow and catches blue No 10 in the chin. Decision?
If the Elbow is deemed foul play, Penalty Blue 5m line (Yellow to Red 7)
If not, drop out 22!
7 -Blue No 10 kicks for the corner. The ball bounces inches from the corner and hits the corner flag. As the ball bounces, but before it hits the corner flag Red No 6 late tackles Blue No 10. Decision?
Penalty to Blue, 5 & 15 !
8 - The ball is kicked down the pitch and comes to rest just in front of the 22 metre line. Blue No 15 reaches forward and plucks the ball back into the 22 and kicks the ball to an opponent who has one foot in touch and catches it on the full. Whose put in and where?
Lineout to Red, from just inside Blue 22
9 - When can the defensive back line encroach the 10 metre law at the line-out before the lineout is over?
When the Lineout is on the 5 metre line !
10 - At what point does the scrum begin?
When the ball leaves the Scrum Halfs' hand
11 - A free kick is awarded 8 metres into in-goal (its a big ingoal). Where must the opposition stand? Can’t award a Free Kick in goal .. Free kick would be awarded 5m line in line with the offence, oppostiton to be 15m from goal line.
12 - Blue 10 kicks off and the ball bobbles in front of the goal line, Red No15 reaches out and grabs the ball and grounds it over the goal line. Decision?
22 Dropout as the ball was still moving when he picked it up !
13 - Blue team throw in at the line-out 5m from their goal-line. They put four players into the lineout, three at the front and one on the 15m line. They throw in. Blue No 6 who is standing on the 15m line catches the ball. His props bind onto him along with the Red forwards, thus forming a Maul. Immediately four of the Blue forwards cross the goal line and start to drive the group of players ahead. Decision?
Penalty to Red, offside, as the lineout is not over !
14 - Blue out-half kicks a kick at goal. Red No 4 reaches up and palms the ball down before it can rise and go over the bar. Decision?
Presuming it was a penalty, award a new penalty 10m from the original kick. You can’t charge a penalty. Warn player!
When is the ball deemed back in play from a penalty kick at goal?
15 - Can you charge down a freekick. If so, at what point?
Yes, immediately once the defender has retired 10 metres.
16 - Blue No 6 passes the ball to Blue No 13 who is 10 metres from the opposition line. As he passes to Blue No 14 who has a free run to the line Red No 12 deliberately knocks on the ball before No 14 can catch it. Decision?
If the actions of Red 12 prevents a probable score (in the mind of the official) award a Penalty Try, & Yellow to Red 12.
17 -At an under 17 match blue team are awarded a scrum, the hooker successfully heels the ball to the back of the scrum and the number 8 controls the ball at the base and the blue team push 1m with the no. 8 controlling the ball at the base. Is this legal.
The ball must be released from the scrum immediately it reaches the No.8’s feet. Free Kick to Red.
18 - Blue No 6 has a blood injury and is replaced by No 19, who is sent off for Foul play after 10 minutes. NO 6 is ready to go back on after 14 minutes and Blue want to take off No 8. Can they do this?
No, (The Blue 19 is deemed to have been sent off in lieu of Blue 6 !)
19 - The throwing in team at a lineout put 7 in the lineout. The defence say them only want to put in 5. Is this legal?
Yes ! The Throwing side determines the Maximum Numbers not Minimum.
20 - Blue No 15 is tactically substituted by No 22 after 50 minutes. This is the only substitution that has been made when after 60 minutes No 22 gets a blood injury and Blue want to put No 15 back on. Can they do this?
Yes a Substituted player can replace a player with a blood injury.
|
See above questions
|
 |
scarletman
Veteran
Married with Kids - Close to Bankruptcy
Joined: 18 August 2004
Location: Wales
Status: Offline
Points: 7268
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 17 May 2011 at 1:38pm |
geej123 wrote:
scarletman wrote:
My take on this !
1 - Blue winger in possession deliberately knees the ball over the heads of the advancing White defenders, regains the ball and dives over in the corner. Decision? Scrum Red ... Knock on as the knee is NOT the foot, so can't be given as a kick.
Would this be a knock on as it does touch another player or the ground?
2 - Red have a scrum on the Blue 5 metre line, Reds No 8 picks the ball up and bumps into the referee, the opposition players are 2 metres away and are affected by the collision. The No 8 passes the ball to the No 14 who scores in the corner. Decision? Scrum Red 5 Metres !
3 - Can you make a tackle if you are on the deck? No !
4 - At a restart from the halfway line Blue 10 drop kicks the ball and it travels over the 10 metre line but the wind catches it midair and blows it back to before the 10 metre line where blue 7 catches it. Decision? Play on ! The only law is that the ball has to travel 10 metres, not land 10 metres !
5 -Red 15 is in his 22 and runs forward to kick left footed for touch. As he does so, his right foot is on his 22 metre line. He kicks directly into the arms of an opposition player who is standing with one foot on the touch line. The ball has not crossed the plane of touch. Who gets the put-in and where? Lineout where the ball was caught by Blue .. Blue Throw in ! The 22 line is inside the 22, just as the Touch Line is in touch !
6 - The ball is passed to blue No 10 who is standing in in-goal, he clears the ball which crosses the goal line but is charged down by red No 7 and goes dead. As he charges the ball down and it goes dead, he follows through with an elbow and catches blue No 10 in the chin. Decision?
If the Elbow is deemed foul play, Penalty Blue 5m line (Yellow to Red 7)
If not, drop out 22!
7 -Blue No 10 kicks for the corner. The ball bounces inches from the corner and hits the corner flag. As the ball bounces, but before it hits the corner flag Red No 6 late tackles Blue No 10. Decision?
Penalty to Blue, 5 & 15 !
8 - The ball is kicked down the pitch and comes to rest just in front of the 22 metre line. Blue No 15 reaches forward and plucks the ball back into the 22 and kicks the ball to an opponent who has one foot in touch and catches it on the full. Whose put in and where?
Lineout to Red, from just inside Blue 22
9 - When can the defensive back line encroach the 10 metre law at the line-out before the lineout is over?
When the Lineout is on the 5 metre line !
10 - At what point does the scrum begin?
When the ball leaves the Scrum Halfs' hand
11 - A free kick is awarded 8 metres into in-goal (its a big ingoal). Where must the opposition stand? Can’t award a Free Kick in goal .. Free kick would be awarded 5m line in line with the offence, oppostiton to be 15m from goal line.
12 - Blue 10 kicks off and the ball bobbles in front of the goal line, Red No15 reaches out and grabs the ball and grounds it over the goal line. Decision?
22 Dropout as the ball was still moving when he picked it up !
13 - Blue team throw in at the line-out 5m from their goal-line. They put four players into the lineout, three at the front and one on the 15m line. They throw in. Blue No 6 who is standing on the 15m line catches the ball. His props bind onto him along with the Red forwards, thus forming a Maul. Immediately four of the Blue forwards cross the goal line and start to drive the group of players ahead. Decision?
Penalty to Red, offside, as the lineout is not over !
14 - Blue out-half kicks a kick at goal. Red No 4 reaches up and palms the ball down before it can rise and go over the bar. Decision?
Presuming it was a penalty, award a new penalty 10m from the original kick. You can’t charge a penalty. Warn player!
When is the ball deemed back in play from a penalty kick at goal?
15 - Can you charge down a freekick. If so, at what point?
Yes, immediately once the defender has retired 10 metres.
16 - Blue No 6 passes the ball to Blue No 13 who is 10 metres from the opposition line. As he passes to Blue No 14 who has a free run to the line Red No 12 deliberately knocks on the ball before No 14 can catch it. Decision?
If the actions of Red 12 prevents a probable score (in the mind of the official) award a Penalty Try, & Yellow to Red 12.
17 -At an under 17 match blue team are awarded a scrum, the hooker successfully heels the ball to the back of the scrum and the number 8 controls the ball at the base and the blue team push 1m with the no. 8 controlling the ball at the base. Is this legal.
The ball must be released from the scrum immediately it reaches the No.8’s feet. Free Kick to Red.
18 - Blue No 6 has a blood injury and is replaced by No 19, who is sent off for Foul play after 10 minutes. NO 6 is ready to go back on after 14 minutes and Blue want to take off No 8. Can they do this?
No, (The Blue 19 is deemed to have been sent off in lieu of Blue 6 !)
19 - The throwing in team at a lineout put 7 in the lineout. The defence say them only want to put in 5. Is this legal?
Yes ! The Throwing side determines the Maximum Numbers not Minimum.
20 - Blue No 15 is tactically substituted by No 22 after 50 minutes. This is the only substitution that has been made when after 60 minutes No 22 gets a blood injury and Blue want to put No 15 back on. Can they do this?
Yes a Substituted player can replace a player with a blood injury.
|
See above questions |
1st query ... The ball has to leave the hands (presumably thrown or dropped in front of the body) to hit the knee, so "knock on" 2nd query ... as stated, you can't charge a penalty kick or do anything to put off the kicker ! unless you just asked a question in general, in which case.. the ball is deemed live after missing/hitting the posts, dropping short or after a restart (KO or 22) following a successful kick / ball dead ! Oh ... & Wouldn't your profile location be more accurate as Chepstow/Bristol ?
Edited by scarletman - 17 May 2011 at 1:40pm
|
|
Member of the Official Scarlets Cyclops Choir (Cardiff 2012)
|
 |
KID A
Moderator Group
Joined: 16 August 2004
Location: Cardiff
Status: Online
Points: 14124
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 17 May 2011 at 1:43pm |
3 - Can you make a tackle if you are on the deck?
No
WHAT IF 2 PLAYERS HAVE BOTH DIVED FOR A BALL GOING TOWARDS THE TOUCHLINE?
6 - The ball is passed to blue No 10 who is standing in in-goal, he clears the ball which crosses the goal line but is charged down by red No 7 and goes dead. As he charges the ball down and it goes dead, he follows through with an elbow and catches blue No 10 in the chin. Decision?
If the Elbow is deemed foul play, Penalty Blue 5m line (
WHY NOT A PENALTY ON THE 22M LINE TO BLUE? AS THAT'S WHERE THE BALL HAS "LANDED"?
14 - Blue out-half kicks a kick at goal. Red No 4 reaches up and palms the ball down before it can rise and go over the bar. Decision?Presuming it was a penalty, award a new penalty 10m from the original kick. You can’t charge a penalty. Warn player!<
why isn't this a tap penalty infront of the posts? can it not be deemed a deliberate knock on?
|
|
|
.
.
|
 |
scarletman
Veteran
Married with Kids - Close to Bankruptcy
Joined: 18 August 2004
Location: Wales
Status: Offline
Points: 7268
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 17 May 2011 at 1:51pm |
KID A wrote:
3 - Can you make a tackle if you are on the deck?
No
WHAT IF 2 PLAYERS HAVE BOTH DIVED FOR A BALL GOING TOWARDS THE TOUCHLINE? This would be "open play" & is not a tackle, to be a tackle on player has to be in posession of the ball & brought to ground by the opposition!
6 - The ball is passed to blue No 10 who is standing in in-goal, he clears the ball which crosses the goal line but is charged down by red No 7 and goes dead. As he charges the ball down and it goes dead, he follows through with an elbow and catches blue No 10 in the chin. Decision?
If the Elbow is deemed foul play, Penalty Blue 5m line (
WHY NOT A PENALTY ON THE 22M LINE TO BLUE? AS THAT'S WHERE THE BALL HAS "LANDED"? Ball went dead (ie over dead ball line) not landed on the 22 ! ? !
14 - Blue out-half kicks a kick at goal. Red No 4 reaches up and palms the ball down before it can rise and go over the bar. Decision?Presuming it was a penalty, award a new penalty 10m from the original kick. You can’t charge a penalty. Warn player!<
why isn't this a tap penalty infront of the posts? can it not be deemed a deliberate knock on? 1st offence is charging the Penalty not deliberate knock on !
|
|
|
|
Member of the Official Scarlets Cyclops Choir (Cardiff 2012)
|
 |
geej123
Newbie
Joined: 01 January 2011
Location: Newport
Status: Offline
Points: 36
|
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Quote Reply
Posted: 18 May 2011 at 12:49pm |
[/QUOTE]
1st query ... The ball has to leave the hands (presumably thrown or dropped in front of the body) to hit the knee, so "knock on" 2nd query ... as stated, you can't charge a penalty kick or do anything to put off the kicker ! unless you just asked a question in general, in which case.. the ball is deemed live after missing/hitting the posts, dropping short or after a restart (KO or 22) following a successful kick / ball dead ! Oh ... & Wouldn't your profile location be more accurate as Chepstow/Bristol ?  [/QUOTE]
yeah the second one was just a general query and not specific to the question.
as for location, when the comment was posted then might have been more accurate, but spend more time in newport as i live the :-)
|
 |